Included below are two concluded court cases from the "online" officer's notebook. If you would like to read all the wildlife and fisheries investigations and the final outcome of the court cases be sure to pick up your Alberta Game Warden magazine at your favorite bookstore. Or better yet, purchase a yearly subscription so you won't miss an issue.

  • Fossil collector digs a big hole for himself: Dinosaur Provincial Park
  • Playing tag: Barrhead District
  • Outfitter and client get knuckles rapped: Barrhead District
  • Judge uses court order to deter poachers and benefit wildlife: Hinton District
  • Hunter catches sheep poacher: Blairmore District
  • Unpaid dues: Sundre District
  • Know your target: Fort McMurray District
  • Hunter helps nab poachers: Fort McMurray District
  • Officers target illegal fishing: Barrhead District
  • Negligence not acceptable: High Prairie District
  • Two moose too many: Slave Lake District
  • Starting the day with a bang: Sundre District
  • Too small to call: Hinton District
  • Pine Creek bullies caught: Athabasca District
  • American hunter slips up: Smoky Lake District
  • Shots ring out in sanctuary: Manning District
  • Caught in wildlife sanctuary: Peace River District
  • Update: The Great White Conviction
Judge uses court order to deter poachers and benefit wildlife: Hinton District 

On Nov. 3, 2003 wildlife officers received information about a headless elk carcass lying in a ditch alongside Highway 40, approximately 20 kilometres south of Hinton. Officers attended the scene and examined the bull elk, which had been shot and left. They photographed it and collected various pieces of evidence. Through the course of their investigation officers were able to make their case. The matters were slated for first appearance on Dec. 3, 2003 but it wasn’t until Aug. 18, 2004 in Hinton Provincial Court that the three men responsible for this act plead guilty to the offences and were sentenced. 

Court heard that on Sunday, Nov. 2, 2003 well after sundown, Michael Aspell, 20, Jason Campell, 20, and Steven Holland, 21, all of Hinton were returning from a drive down Highway 40 to the Gregg River Mine area when Aspell spotted a large antlered 6X6 bull elk along the roadway. Commenting on the size of the elk, Aspell turned Holland’s truck around and proceeded back towards the animal. Pointing the headlights of the truck in the animal’s direction, Aspell, without exiting the vehicle, opened fire on the elk with his rifle. After lunging a few steps the elk collapsed and rolled down the embankment to the ditch alongside the highway. 
    With their hopes of having the elk run back into the trees now dashed, they drove away from the animal and discussed what to do. Returning a short while later, the three worked together to remove the head from the carcass. Unable to load the rest of the elk into their truck, they fastened the head and antlers to the rear of their vehicle and headed for Hinton. After traveling approximately 10 kilometres, a decision was made to cache the head alongside the highway and return for it at a later time. Although they claimed to have discussed numerous ways in which they might salvage the carcass, none of those options were pursued.
    Upon relaying the circumstances to the Honorable Judge D.C. Norheim, crown prosecutor Bob Marr offered a plea to which the defense acknowledged was ‘low for this court’ but reminded the court that the global assessment was nearing $5,000 to which a fair portion would be put back towards the resource. The initial penalty submission set forth that half of any fines administered by the courts be payable through anorder which would direct the funds back through the Fish and Wildlife Dedicated Revenue Initiative, towards promoting the proper management and control of conservation and protection of wildlife or endangered species, or both, or their habitats. 
     Marr related that in the past, orders made pursuant to section 97 of the Wildlife Act, a section that provides for additional powers of the court to make direction, had not always been simply resolved. In this particular case the accused’s defense counsel had already received a sizable portion of these funds and they were currently being held in trust. Judge Norheim accepted the joint submissions, however, he made one slight adjustment. Instead of the suggested 50 per cent allocation of funds being directed through an order back to the resource, he ordered the majority. 
    To Michael Aspell, guilty pleas on charges of closed season hunting, hunting at night and allowing the edible flesh of a big game animal to be abandoned, Judge Norheim sentenced Aspell to a $100 fine on each count. Judge Norheim further ordered that Aspell pay, pursuant to a section 97 order, the sum of $2,700 no later than Oct. 13, 2004 to the Fish and Wildlife Dedicated Revenue Initiative, to promote the proper management and protection of the resource, namely that the funds be used for grizzly bear education efforts in the southwest region. Steven Holland plead guilty to a charge of unlawful possession of wildlife and was sentenced to a $100 fine and was ordered to pay an additional sum of $900 towards the same initiative. Jason Campell was assessed a $100 fine and ordered to pay $400 to the initiative. 
     It was further proposed by both defense and Crown that these orders be monitored to ensure that they are dealt with before the court imposed fine. Time to pay was extended to Oct. 13, 2004 to further compel payment. All additional charges related to this case were put over to that date as well. Judge Norheim commented favourably on the option to utilize the section 97 orders to direct funds back to the resource, and although it was the first time they had been proposed in his court, he hoped it would not be the last.

 

Officers target illegal fishing: Barrhead District 

    In 1997, as part of a new walleye management regime, lakes in Alberta were classified as either stable, vulnerable or collapsed, depending on the status of the walleye population in that water body. Lac Ste. Anne was placed in the collapsed category and given a zero limit for walleye, meaning catch and release only. 
    Since 1997 the walleye population has steadily increased. Along with this increase the number of illegal fishing complaints has also gone up. Fish and Wildlife has received 15 complaints of illegal fishing since the lake opened on May 21, 2004 for the open water fishing season. The majority of complaints were lodged through the Report APoacher hotline by other concerned sportsmen. Eight of those reports were related to the keeping of walleye. 
    Officers from Barrhead, Evansburg, Stony Plain and Edmonton have teamed up to put a dent in the illegal fishing. In the five-month open water period, officers have logged approximately 53 patrols of the lake resulting in enforcement actions being taken against 46 persons. The majority of the cases involved over-limits, undersized fish or licensing offences. 
    On October 6, 2004 two of the court cases were heard in Stony Plain provincial court by Judge W.M. Mustard. 
    One case involved two Westlock men who were fishing at the narrows of the lake. On August 16, 2004 Arnold George Kuipers, 45, and David Michael Forbes, 42, were caught with 13 walleye hidden in a bag under a blanket in the trunk of their car. Each received a $1,500 fine and a three-year sportfishing licence suspension. 
    The second case involved three Edmonton men who were also fishing at the narrows. Court heard that on August 18, 2004 Fish and Wildlife officers conducted a plainclothes operation at the narrows. They observed Thai Vo, 35, Thanh Chau, 42, and Thuc Tran, 26, fishing in an area of tall weeds away from the other fishermen. Officers observed them catching and keeping walleye. Uniformed officers were called in and found eight fresh walleye laying on the ground at the rear of a van. Although they initially denied catching the fish, they were identified by plainclothes officers. Each received a $1,200 fine and a three-year sportfishing licence suspension.


We invite wildlife and fisheries enforcement officers from all jurisdictions to submit current and significant cases for inclusion in The Notebook segment of the publication. All details must be accurate public record. Please send case file details and photographs to:


THE ALBERTA GAME WARDEN
Jason Hanson
5201 - 50 Avenue
Wetaskiwin, Alberta, Canada T9A 0S7